Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

Creation of CSIS made Canada less safe: ex-Mountie

Last Updated: Wednesday, March 7, 2007 | 4:53 PM ET

Stripping the RCMP of responsibility for intelligence-gathering and handing the job over to CSIS made Canada a more dangerous place, not a safer one, a former senior Mountie says.
  
Henry Jensen, testifying Wednesday at the public inquiry in Ottawa into the Air India bombing, stopped short of drawing a direct link between the creation of CSIS in 1984 and the terrorist attack that took place the following year.
  
But he painted a rosy picture of the way intelligence operations had been run under the RCMP, and contrasted that with the difficulties that plagued the new regime.
  
The assertions led Justice John Major, the head of the inquiry, to wonder whether things improved by the time Jensen retired from his post as deputy commissioner of the national police force in 1989.
  
"Was Canada a safer place as a result of CSIS being cut out of the RCMP?" the judge asked.
  
"You want my honest opinion?" Jensen replied. "No. I think Canada became a riskier place, certainly, in that period of time."
  
Rivalry between CSIS and the Mounties has been widely blamed for the failure to head off the Air India attack, and for recurring problems that dogged the criminal investigation that followed.
  
When Major raised the issue, Jensen was quick to absolve his former police colleagues and put the blame for precipitating the turf war squarely on the other side.
  
"Within the RCMP I did not notice that," he said. "With respect to the new CSIS organization, yes, I felt they believed that there was an issue [of] staking out their turf."
  
Others have been less charitable in assessing the role played by the RCMP in the conflict.
  
CSIS was spun off as a separate agency in 1984, after an inquiry by Justice David McDonald uncovered evidence that the old RCMP security service had committed criminal acts — including burning a barn and stealing dynamite — in the name of fighting Quebec separatism.

Limited by law

But the new intelligence agency was limited by law to collecting information and monitoring security threats. It had no authority to arrest anyone or lay criminal charges, powers that remained with the RCMP.
  
Jean-Paul Brodeur, a national security expert at the  Université de Montreal, testified Wednesday that things were complicated by the fact that Robert Simmonds, then the RCMP commissioner, never really accepted his force's loss of the security role.
  
"The RCMP felt that terrorism was a crime and it belonged to them," Brodeur said. "So you had two investigative agencies that were competing against each other."
  
The crunch came barely a year after the creation of CSIS, when Air India Flight 182 was downed by a terrorist bomb in June 1985 with the loss of 329 lives.
  
The attack was blamed on militant Sikh separatists in British Columbia, but only one man was ever convicted for his role in the plot. Another was shot dead by Indian police in 1992 and two more were acquitted in Vancouver in 2005.
  
CSIS had some of the suspects under surveillance before the attack and shared much of its intelligence with the RCMP during the subsequent criminal investigation. But key wiretap tapes were erased, and other material couldn't meet the legal test for use in court.

Under one roof

Jensen, who was in charge of RCMP criminal operations for most of the 1980s, contended Wednesday that relations with intelligence officers were smoother when everyone worked under one roof at the RCMP.
  
"It was a co-operative arrangement," he told Major. "Our files were open to the security service [and] security service files were open to us."
  
Once CSIS was created, the Mounties signed a memorandum with the new agency that they hoped would ensure the same unfettered access. In Jensen's view, CSIS had a duty to turn over anything the RCMP needed for a criminal prosecution: "It was mandatory, not discretionary."
  
Major appeared to have trouble accepting that interpretation, noting that the whole point of creating CSIS was to separate intelligence powers from police powers.
  
Replied Jensen: "In its wisdom, the government of the day chose that path — and left us with the problems."
  

More Canada Headlines »

Canadian soldier charged in comrade's shooting death
The military's National Investigation Service has charged a Canadian soldier in the shooting death of Master Cpl. Jeffrey Walsh in Afghanistan.
B.C. husband charged with murdering pregnant wife
The husband and brother-in-law of Surrey mother and school teacher Manjit Panghali, whose badly burned body was found in Delta last October, have been arrested and charged in connection with her death.
Woman who hid in Ontario church can stay in Canada
A woman who hid in a Kingston, Ont., church and was pardoned for manslaughter during her long fight to stay in Canada has been granted landed immigrant status.
Dirty air in arenas could pose health risk: CBC investigation Video: Jo Lynne Sheane reports for CBC-TV
The polluted air inside some Canadian hockey arenas could be putting people at risk, a CBC News investigation reveals.
Aboriginal protest blocks western Quebec highway
About 50 aboriginal demonstrators blocked a highway in western Quebec's Outaouais region Monday in a protest over logging and living conditions.
Story Tools: E-MAIL | PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

World must protect Darfur civilians from war crimes: UN Video: Harry Forestell reports for CBC-TV
A UN team says the world has an urgent obligation to protect civilians in Darfur from war crimes and crimes against humanity in which the Sudanese government is playing a major role.
Hillier visits troops in Afghanistan Video: Laura Lynch reports for CBC-TV
Canada's top soldier paid a surprise visit to Afghanistan Monday, a day after the defence minister arrived in the country.
Weather aids crews battling L.A. area brush fire
Cool morning conditions Monday helped crews battling a brush fire near Los Angeles that threatened a hillside residential area and forced more than 1,200 people from their homes.
more »

Canada »

Canadian soldier charged in comrade's shooting death
The military's National Investigation Service has charged a Canadian soldier in the shooting death of Master Cpl. Jeffrey Walsh in Afghanistan.
B.C. husband charged with murdering pregnant wife
The husband and brother-in-law of Surrey mother and school teacher Manjit Panghali, whose badly burned body was found in Delta last October, have been arrested and charged in connection with her death.
Woman who hid in Ontario church can stay in Canada
A woman who hid in a Kingston, Ont., church and was pardoned for manslaughter during her long fight to stay in Canada has been granted landed immigrant status.
more »

Health »

Office workers prone to blood clots
Staying chained to your desk might place you at greater risk of potentially fatal blood clots in the legs, researchers in New Zealand say.
Quebec losing ground in cancer fight, say specialists
Cancer researchers are urging Quebec politicians to come up with concrete measures to fight what they say is the province's No. 1 killer.
Dirty air in arenas could pose health risk: CBC investigation Video: Jo Lynne Sheane reports for CBC-TV
The polluted air inside some Canadian hockey arenas could be putting people at risk, a CBC News investigation reveals.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Controversy dogs Rock and Roll Hall of Fame choices
With Eddie Van Halen in rehab and Ronette's producer Phil Spector, who is facing a trial for allegedly killing an actress, the induction ceremony for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame on Monday evening could be most notable for its absences.
Da Vinci work crated for loan despite Italian protests
An Italian senator followed through Monday on his earlier promise to chain himself to the gates of Italy's famed Uffizi Gallery to protest the loan of an early Leonardo da Vinci work to Japan.
Break a leg, say gamblers, as Mills enters dance contest
Interest is mounting in the return of TV's Dancing With the Stars next week, or more specifically, in the participation of British activist and former model Heather Mills.
more »

Technology & Science »

Rocket launches satellites for Britain, India
A European rocket carrying two British and Indian satellites was successfully launched Sunday from South America after a one-day delay due to a technical glitch.
Stocky build gave ape-like ancestors a leg up
The short legs and squat physique of the ape-like human ancestors known as australopiths made them better fighters, according to a study published this month.
Intel launches new flash memory storage
Intel unveiled a new storage device based on flash memory on Monday, the latest move in the high-tech world toward the smaller, sturdier memory format.
more »

Money »

Computer tax filing to resume by Thursday: CRA
Canadians should again be able to e-file their tax returns by Thursday at the latest, the Canada Revenue Agency said Monday.
Regulators file charges against Dunn, 3 other former Nortel executives Video: Jeannie Lee reports for CBC-TV
Stock market regulators in Canada and the United States filed several charges Monday against several former Nortel Networks executives, including fired CEO Frank Dunn.
Mackenzie gas project to cost $16.2B: Imperial Oil
The cost of the proposed Mackenzie natural gas project in the NWT is now pegged at $16.2 billion and production startup will be no sooner than 2014, says Imperial Oil.
more »

Consumer Life »

Quebec man wins fight over city's huge parking fee increase
A Quebec man has won his fight to reduce overnight parking fees in Cote-St-Luc after city council raised fees in January from $120 to $420.
Computer tax filing to resume by Thursday: CRA
Canadians should again be able to e-file their tax returns by Thursday at the latest, the Canada Revenue Agency said Monday.
Dirty air in arenas could pose health risk: CBC investigation Video: Jo Lynne Sheane reports for CBC-TV
The polluted air inside some Canadian hockey arenas could be putting people at risk, a CBC News investigation reveals.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Raptors shoot for 3rd straight win
Raptors guard T.J. Ford will try to extend his hot-streak Monday night against his former team when Toronto visits the Milwaukee Bucks.
Eskimos release Mobley, Brady
Linebacker Singor Mobley and defensive back Donald Brady's lengthy stints with the Edmonton Eskimos came to an end Monday when the CFL club released the veteran pair.
Lundqvist named NHL's first star
New York Rangers goaltender Henrik Lundqvist was selected the NHL's first star of the week on Monday.
more »